Second star to the right and straight on 'till morning.
The fact that Emily, Spencer, Aria and Alison all see that Hanna is losing her shit, in this toxic/Loveish relationship with Caleb (because she’s hurting, he’s familiar, he’s hurting, she’s familiar..they need some type of comfort..familiarity but they still love each other), She’s drinking,…
I’m a strong supporter of the “Toby is A” theory. I found it kind of weird what he told Spencer in 5x05, it went something like this. “You are never alone, not even for a second.”
Doesn’t A and the A team watch them all the time? I feel like this is a big hint that Toby is Uber A.
In 5X05, pie scene, right before the hot sex, Ezra says to Aria:
"This is what she did to me. I’m lucky to be alive and so are you. Just like she told you, remember? Shana wasn’t playing a game.”
I know abs are out in the open so it’s hard to focus on the dialogue but once I heard him say…
Oh My God!! That is freaking Brilliant, I mean Shana did say that Ali was almost killed that night. That would be a perfect explanation to her scar. Genius!!!